Car Insurance Claim Process in South Africa: Step-by-Step Guide

I still remember the first time I had to file a car insurance claim. I was sitting on the side of the N1, staring at the cracked bumper of my little hatchback, with that sinking feeling in my stomach. Do I call the police first? Do I phone the insurance company? Am I supposed to take pictures before I move the car? In that moment, the “process” felt like a mystery wrapped in panic.

If you’ve ever been in an accident, you’ll know what I mean. It’s not just about the dent in the car—it’s the confusion, the paperwork, the worry about whether the insurer will actually pay out. The good news? Once you understand how the claim process works in South Africa, it stops feeling like a maze. Let’s break it down, step by step, with some real-world context sprinkled in.

Why Knowing the Claim Process Matters

Car insurance is one of those things you hope you’ll never need, but when you do, you want it to work seamlessly. South African roads, though, can be unpredictable. Between potholes that appear overnight, minibus taxis weaving into gaps that don’t exist, and the occasional careless driver, accidents are not exactly rare.

But here’s where it gets tricky: many people think that simply having insurance guarantees a payout. Not always. Missing a step—or even delaying too long—can jeopardize your claim. Knowing the process is less about bureaucracy and more about protecting yourself from unnecessary stress.

Step 1: Stay Calm and Check for Safety

Before worrying about forms or phone calls, the first priority is people’s safety. If there are injuries, your first call should be for medical assistance. South African law also requires you to report accidents that cause injury, death, or significant property damage.

I’ll admit, in my own accident, I forgot half of this. I was more worried about whether my insurer would cover a new bumper than checking if the other driver needed help. In hindsight, that was foolish—and potentially dangerous.

So the rule of thumb is:

Check injuries first. Call emergency services if needed.

Move vehicles only if it’s safe. On a busy road, leaving cars in place can cause secondary accidents.

Switch on hazards and use warning triangles.

Your claim can wait a few minutes. Safety can’t.

Step 2: Report the Incident to the Police

Here’s where many South Africans slip up. Even if the accident seems “minor,” you often need a police case number to complete your insurance claim. Most insurers won’t process claims without it—especially for theft, hijacking, or accidents involving another vehicle.

When I went to the police station, I half expected a quick five-minute process. Instead, I found myself waiting in line with half a dozen other frustrated motorists. The paperwork was tedious, but that case number turned out to be the golden ticket for my insurer. Without it, my claim would have gone nowhere.

Pro tip: Write the case number down in more than one place. I once watched a friend frantically dig through old SMS messages trying to retrieve his case number, only to delay his payout by weeks.

Step 3: Gather Evidence (Photos, Details, Witnesses)

This step feels awkward when you’re standing on the side of the road with the other driver glaring at you. But trust me, it’s important. Your insurer will want every detail they can get:

Photos of damage to all cars involved

The accident scene (skid marks, traffic signs, weather conditions)

Driver and vehicle details (license plates, IDs, contact numbers)

Witness names and numbers, if available

One mistake I made? I only photographed my own car. Later, my insurer asked for pictures of the other vehicle, and I had nothing to show. It didn’t ruin my claim, but it slowed things down.

And if you’re in a hijacking or theft situation, photos aren’t possible—but jot down the time, place, and as much detail as you can remember.

Step 4: Notify Your Insurer Quickly

South African insurers usually require you to report an accident within 24 to 48 hours. Some are even stricter. Miss the deadline, and you may discover that your carefully paid premiums were for nothing.

When I made my call, I was surprised by how many questions they asked. It wasn’t just “What happened?” They wanted dates, times, the police case number, whether I’d had a drink that night (fair question, I suppose), and even what lane I was driving in.

It felt like an interrogation, but remember: insurers need to filter out fraudulent claims. Providing honest and consistent information helps your case.

Step 5: Complete the Claim Form

This is where things move from phone calls to paperwork. Most insurers will email you a claim form, and you’ll need to fill it in accurately. It’s tempting to gloss over details or exaggerate to make yourself look less at fault—but that can backfire.

Some insurers also let you complete the claim online or via their mobile app. While that sounds convenient, don’t rush it. Double-check dates, spellings, and accident descriptions. Small errors can cause long delays.

Step 6: Vehicle Assessment

Once your claim is logged, the insurer usually sends your car to an approved panel beater or assessment centre. They’ll evaluate the damage and send a repair quote back to the insurer.

Now, here’s the catch: you don’t always get to choose where your car goes. Many insurers have a “preferred network” of repairers, and if you insist on using your own, you might have to pay extra.

When my car was assessed, I remember nervously waiting for the verdict. Was it a “repair” case, or was my little hatchback about to be declared a write-off? Insurers will compare the repair cost against the car’s value. If fixing it costs more than about 70% of what the car is worth, they usually scrap it and pay you the market value instead.

Step 7: Approval and Excess Payment

If everything checks out, the insurer approves the claim. But before repairs begin, you’ll usually have to pay your excess—the portion of the cost you’re responsible for.

This part always stings. You can be paying premiums for years without a single claim, and then suddenly you’re shelling out thousands in excess. But that’s how risk-sharing works. It’s worth checking your policy beforehand, because some excesses are higher than people expect.

Step 8: Repairs or Settlement

At this stage, things finally start to feel like progress. Your car goes in for repairs, or you receive a payout if it’s written off. Repair times can vary—some panel beaters are efficient, others seem to take an eternity.

If your insurer offers a courtesy car, use it. I learned the hard way when I declined one (thinking repairs would be quick) and ended up Ubering everywhere for two weeks. Not fun on the wallet.

Step 9: Follow-Up and Closure

Even after repairs, don’t assume everything is wrapped up. Check your vehicle carefully before signing it off. Are the repairs done properly? Are there issues with paintwork or alignment? Once you sign, it’s harder to argue later.

Also, keep an eye on your no-claims bonus or premium adjustments. Some insurers will increase your premiums after a claim, while others won’t if you weren’t at fault. It pays to ask.

Common Pitfalls That Derail Claims

Let’s be honest—insurance claims in South Africa don’t always run smoothly. Some common stumbling blocks include:

Late reporting: Waiting a week before phoning the insurer.

Incomplete documentation: Missing police case numbers or incorrect details.

Non-disclosure: Forgetting to mention an extra driver or prior damage.

Policy misunderstandings: Thinking you’re covered for theft when you only have third-party insurance.

I once knew someone who assumed their insurance covered hail damage. It didn’t. A summer storm left their car looking like a golf ball, and the insurer politely declined the claim. Painful lesson.

A Few Personal Takeaways

If I could give advice to my younger self (the one panicking on the N1 with a smashed bumper), it would be:

Save your insurer’s emergency number in your phone. Don’t go Googling in the moment.

Keep a small accident kit in your car—pen, notepad, disposable camera (or just make sure your phone is charged), and a warning triangle.

Don’t rush through the claim process. A few extra minutes gathering details can save weeks later.

And above all, remember: insurers aren’t the enemy. Yes, they’re cautious, sometimes painfully so, but they’re also your safety net when life throws a curveball.

Final Thoughts

Filing a car insurance claim in South Africa isn’t glamorous, and it rarely feels convenient. But it doesn’t have to be overwhelming. The process, while sometimes frustrating, is fairly structured: safety, police report, evidence, notify insurer, fill forms, assessment, approval, excess, and finally, repairs or settlement.

If you go into it knowing the steps—and maybe with a story or two of your own—you’ll find it a lot less intimidating. And when that day comes (hopefully it never does), you’ll be ready, not scrambling on the roadside like I once was.

Published on: Sep 11, 2025

Related Post