Hollard Car Insurance: Affordable or Overrated?

Car insurance is one of those things you don’t think about much until you’re staring at a quote, wondering whether the monthly debit order will choke your budget. In South Africa, where car theft and accident rates are high enough to make your heart race, picking an insurance provider is not just a formality—it’s survival. And Hollard, one of the most recognizable names in the industry, often finds itself pitched as the “affordable yet reliable” option.

But is Hollard really giving you value for money, or are we all just buying into clever branding and slick advertising? That’s the uncomfortable question that sits in the back of many drivers’ minds. Let’s unpack it—carefully, and maybe a little skeptically.

The Familiarity Factor: Why Hollard Pops Up Everywhere

If you drive through Johannesburg or Cape Town long enough, you’ll probably spot a Hollard billboard. Their marketing presence is hard to ignore. They’ve positioned themselves as approachable, community-driven, and somewhat quirky compared to the stiffer, more “corporate” insurance players like Santam or Discovery Insure.

I’ll admit, when I bought my first car—a battered but dependable Toyota Corolla—I didn’t shop around much. Hollard was the name that popped up first, partly because their ads had already made themselves comfortable in my subconscious. They felt affordable before I even checked the numbers. That, of course, is the genius of branding.

Still, brand familiarity doesn’t always equal value.

What “Affordable” Actually Means in Insurance

Here’s the tricky bit: affordability in car insurance is slippery. Hollard may offer lower premiums upfront, but “affordable” only tells part of the story. It ignores things like:

Excess payments: That dreaded lump sum you must cough up before the insurer pays the rest of your claim. A lower monthly premium often hides a higher excess.

Coverage gaps: Some policies look cheap because they exclude things you might assume are covered—like roadside assistance or hail damage.

Claim process pain: What’s affordable in theory might become costly in practice if you’re left carless for weeks while paperwork drags on.

I’ve heard stories from friends who swore Hollard was the cheapest option until they had to file a claim. Suddenly, “affordable” felt like a bait-and-switch. One friend had a fender bender, and while the premium was low, the excess was nearly half the cost of fixing her car.

So yes, Hollard can be affordable. But you’ve got to ask: affordable compared to what, and at what point in the insurance journey?

The Value Proposition: Coverage vs. Price

On paper, Hollard offers the same basic options as most competitors:

Comprehensive Insurance – Covers damage to your own car and others, theft, fire, natural disasters.

Third-Party Only – Just covers damage you cause to other people’s cars or property.

Third-Party, Fire, and Theft – A middle-ground policy.

Nothing revolutionary here. But what makes people lean toward Hollard is their pitch: similar coverage at a lower rate.

The question is whether that’s genuinely the case once you compare apples with apples. Some competitors throw in roadside assistance, car hire, or no-claims bonuses as sweeteners. Hollard may look cheaper but doesn’t always bundle those extras.

This reminds me of grocery shopping. You buy the cheaper loaf of bread, only to realize the slices are smaller and you’re back at the store sooner. Was it really cheaper?

Customer Experiences: Stories That Don’t Match the Brochure

Insurance reviews are a minefield—people usually only write them when they’re angry. But trawl through enough Trustpilot comments, social media threads, or even braai-side conversations, and you’ll notice patterns.

Some Hollard customers rave about fast, no-nonsense claims processing. “They sorted me out within a week,” one colleague told me, after her windscreen cracked on the N1. Others? Not so rosy. Complaints range from claims being declined on “technicalities” to endless delays in payouts.

A friend of mine, Sipho, had his car stolen. His Hollard claim was approved, but it dragged on for weeks, leaving him Ubering to work while waiting for the settlement. He admitted the premium was fair, but the delay cost him far more in frustration and out-of-pocket expenses than he’d saved on his monthly bill.

That’s the thing: with insurance, the company’s real character only shows up when things go wrong. Hollard seems to sit in the middle of the pack—not the worst, but not consistently shining either.

Who Actually Benefits from Hollard?

Here’s where nuance comes in. Hollard does make sense for certain types of drivers:

Young drivers or students: They’re already considered high-risk, so Hollard’s competitive pricing can ease the burden.

People with older cars: If your car’s market value is modest, you might not need bells-and-whistles coverage, and Hollard’s stripped-down options could suit you.

Drivers who rarely claim: If you’re confident in your cautious driving habits, lower premiums with higher excess might actually be a smart gamble.

But if you’ve just bought a shiny new Hilux or BMW, would Hollard’s affordability be enough peace of mind? Maybe not. In that case, you might prefer the more premium insurers who make car hire and concierge-like claims support part of the package.

The “Overrated” Argument

Now, is Hollard overrated? Some would argue yes. They’ve built such a strong brand that many people sign on without comparing alternatives. Discovery, OUTsurance, and even King Price sometimes match or undercut Hollard’s pricing, depending on your profile.

Another point critics raise: Hollard’s service can be inconsistent across regions. You might hear glowing reviews in Gauteng, yet stories of frustration in smaller towns where their partner networks are thinner. That inconsistency feeds the sense that Hollard is a bit more hype than substance.

To be fair, though, isn’t this true of most big insurers? The gap between expectation and reality seems almost universal in the industry.

My Take: The Human Side of Insurance

Personally, when I insured my Corolla years ago, Hollard was fine—cheap enough, and I never had to claim, so I can’t fault them. But when I upgraded to a newer car, I switched. Why? Not because Hollard failed me, but because I wanted extras like guaranteed car hire if mine was in for repairs. I realized paying slightly more gave me the convenience and peace of mind that “affordable” alone couldn’t buy.

That’s the rub with Hollard: if your priority is shaving rands off your monthly debit order, they deliver. But if you’re the kind of person who needs hand-holding when things go wrong, Hollard might leave you a little underwhelmed.

Final Thoughts: Affordable and Overrated?

So, back to the big question: is Hollard Car Insurance affordable or overrated? The frustrating answer is… both.

They’re affordable in the sense that they often beat out bigger players on raw premium pricing. But “overrated” creeps in when you consider coverage gaps, claim delays, and the marketing sheen that sometimes oversells the reality.

If you’re considering Hollard, the smarter move isn’t to ask whether they’re cheap. The real question is: cheap compared to what, and what are you willing to sacrifice for the price?

At the end of the day, car insurance is one of those products where you only find out whether you chose well when disaster strikes. Until then, Hollard will probably continue sitting comfortably in the middle of South Africa’s insurance landscape—affordable enough to attract attention, but not always as impressive as the billboards suggest.

Published on: Sep 11, 2025

Related Post