How Car Insurance Premiums Are Calculated in South Africa

I still remember the first time I got a car insurance quote in South Africa. I had just bought a second-hand Polo Vivo. I was thrilled—until the broker read out my monthly premium. My jaw nearly hit the desk. How could someone who barely drove outside Johannesburg’s city limits be paying that much? That’s when I learned that car insurance premiums aren’t as simple as “safe driver equals low cost.” They’re shaped by a whole collection of factors, some obvious and others surprisingly subtle.

If you’ve ever looked at your car insurance statement and thought, Why am I paying this much?, you’re not alone. Let’s unpack how insurance companies in South Africa calculate premiums. And I’ll sprinkle in some stories and observations along the way—because numbers alone don’t always tell the full picture.

The Basics: What an Insurance Premium Really Is

At its core, your premium is the amount you pay an insurer each month (or annually, if you prefer) for coverage. But it’s not just pulled from thin air. Insurers are running a very calculated balancing act: they’re trying to predict how much risk you, personally, pose. The higher the perceived risk, the more you’ll pay.

But here’s the tricky part: “risk” isn’t just about whether you’ve had an accident before. It’s an entire profile insurers build around you, your car, and even your lifestyle.

Factor 1: The Type of Car You Drive

One of the first things an insurer looks at is your car itself. That little hatchback or flashy SUV isn’t just transport—it’s data in their system.

Car model and make: A luxury BMW 3 Series is going to cost more to insure than a Toyota Corolla. Why? Repairs and replacement parts. The Corolla is cheaper to fix, and statistically, it’s less likely to be stolen than a German sedan.

Engine size: Cars with bigger engines—think performance vehicles—often have higher premiums. The assumption is that they’ll be driven faster, with more risk involved.

Safety features: If your car has airbags, ABS brakes, immobilisers, or tracking devices, you may see a reduction in your premium. Some insurers will even insist you install a tracker before they’ll cover a high-risk model.

A friend of mine drives a 2007 Citi Golf, and his insurance is oddly high for such an old car. Why? Because Citi Golfs are notorious targets for theft in South Africa. So while he thinks his car is a humble oldie, insurers see it as a high-risk magnet.

Factor 2: Your Driving History

This one makes intuitive sense, but it can sting if you’ve had a bad run.

Accident history: If you’ve had multiple accidents, insurers assume you’re statistically more likely to have another. Even if the last one wasn’t your fault, the pattern raises their eyebrows.

Traffic violations: Speeding fines, reckless driving, or DUI records will almost always increase your premium.

Claims history: If you’re someone who claims for every scratch and ding, insurers may tag you as “high maintenance.”

I had a minor fender-bender at a traffic circle a few years ago. I decided not to claim—it cost me a couple of thousand rand out of pocket, but it spared me a long-term bump in premiums. It felt unfair at the time, but insurers do see claims (even small ones) as indicators of risk.

Factor 3: Your Age and Gender

Here’s where it gets controversial.

Young drivers (especially under 25): You’re statistically more likely to be involved in accidents if you’re young, particularly a young male. So premiums are often higher for this group.

Older drivers: On the flip side, older drivers may pay less—up to a point. But once you’re seen as a “senior driver,” premiums can creep up again due to slower reflexes and higher accident risks.

Is it fair? Some argue no, because not every 22-year-old drives like a Formula 1 rookie. But insurance is based on patterns, not personal exceptions. That’s the tension—you could be the safest young driver in South Africa and still pay more than a middle-aged parent with a less spotless record.

Factor 4: Where You Live and Park

Your postal code says more about you than you think.

High-crime areas: If you live in a suburb where hijackings and thefts are common, your premium will reflect that.

Parking situation: Do you keep your car in a locked garage, behind a gate, or out on the street? The more secure, the lower the risk—and the cheaper the insurance.

I once moved from Pretoria to Cape Town, and my insurer actually dropped my premium slightly because the suburb I moved to had a lower crime rate. That’s how sensitive insurers are to geography.

Factor 5: How Much (and How) You Drive

The more time you spend on the road, the more chances there are for something to go wrong. Insurers know this, so they look at:

Annual mileage: Someone commuting 50 km daily is going to pay more than someone who just drives to the shops on weekends.

Type of driving: City traffic with lots of stop-start chaos carries higher risks than open-road rural driving.

Some insurers even offer “low mileage” discounts. If you’re working from home and barely driving, it may be worth asking your insurer to review your premium.

Factor 6: The Type of Coverage You Choose

Your premium also depends on what you’re actually insured for.

Comprehensive insurance: Covers theft, hijacking, accidents, fire, weather damage, and more. It’s the most expensive, but also the most complete.

Third-party, fire, and theft: Covers damage to other people’s property plus theft/fire of your own car. Cheaper, but less protection.

Third-party only: Bare-bones cover for damage you cause to others. Cheapest, but leaves your own car unprotected.

Here’s the kicker: sometimes choosing a higher excess (the amount you pay out of pocket before the insurer covers the rest) can lower your monthly premium. But that’s a gamble—you’re betting on not needing to claim often.

Factor 7: Credit Score and Financial Behaviour

Not everyone realises this, but insurers also look at your financial reliability. A strong credit record may suggest you’re responsible and less likely to default on payments—or even take unnecessary risks.

On the flip side, a poor credit history can push your premiums up. It feels judgmental, but insurers argue that there’s a statistical link between financial responsibility and claim behaviour.

Factor 8: Extra Add-Ons and Customisation

Did you install a sound system worth R20,000? Or maybe you’ve tricked out your bakkie with custom rims and bull bars. Insurers see these as added risks—not just because they’re worth more, but because they attract theft.

Optional extras like roadside assistance, car hire, or cover for personal belongings also nudge your premium higher.

Why Premiums Differ Between Insurers

Here’s something that frustrates a lot of drivers: two different insurance companies can give wildly different quotes for the same person and car. Why? Because each company has its own risk models, historical claim data, and appetite for certain customers.

One insurer may see your sporty hatchback as a liability, while another sees you as low risk because of your age, profession, or security setup. That’s why it’s always worth comparing at least three or four quotes before settling.

The Human Side: Psychology in Premiums

It’s easy to reduce insurance to cold numbers, but there’s also psychology at play. Insurers know that many people are drawn to “peace of mind,” so they may upsell more comprehensive packages even if the odds of certain risks are slim.

And drivers, in turn, sometimes accept higher premiums because of fear—fear of hijacking, fear of debt after an accident, fear of being stranded without a car.

Ways to Lower Your Premium

So, after all this, what can you actually do to pay less? Here are a few strategies that have worked for me and others:

Install a tracker or immobiliser. Some insurers won’t budge without it, but for others, it’s a discount trigger.

Bundle insurance products. Insure your car, home, and valuables with the same company and you’ll often get a better deal.

Review annually. Your premium isn’t set in stone. If your situation changes—like moving suburbs or driving less—ask for a reassessment.

Increase your excess. Risky, but effective if you don’t claim often.

Maintain a clean record. Both on the road and financially.

A Final Word: It’s Not Just About Price

Here’s what I’ve learned after years of juggling quotes and policies: the cheapest premium isn’t always the best. When I had that minor accident at the traffic circle, I was grateful I hadn’t gone with the absolute cheapest insurer. They actually processed the claim efficiently and didn’t haggle over every cent.

Insurance, at the end of the day, is about balancing risk, peace of mind, and affordability. The formula may feel unfair at times, but knowing how it’s built gives you some power back.

Published on: Sep 11, 2025

Related Post