OUTsurance vs. Santam: Which Car Insurance Offers Better Value?

Choosing car insurance can feel like wandering through a maze blindfolded—so many options, each promising “the best” or “unbeatable value.” If you’re South African and trying to decide between OUTsurance and Santam, you’re not alone. I’ve spent some time comparing the two, and I’ll share what I discovered—warts and all. Hopefully, my experience can help you make sense of the often-confusing car insurance landscape.

Understanding the Contenders

Before jumping into who comes out on top, let’s set the stage. OUTsurance and Santam are both well-known players in South Africa’s insurance market, but they cater to slightly different tastes and priorities.

OUTsurance tends to appeal to people who like a simple, straightforward experience. They often market themselves as customer-friendly, with features like cash-back rewards if you don’t claim, and a strong online claims system. For someone like me, who doesn’t like endless paperwork, that kind of convenience is tempting.

Santam, on the other hand, carries the weight of legacy. It’s one of South Africa’s oldest insurers and has a reputation for comprehensive cover. They tend to emphasize tailored policies, meaning you can theoretically build a plan that suits your car, your lifestyle, and your comfort level with risk. But—and this is important—tailored policies aren’t always straightforward. Sometimes you end up paying for bells and whistles you don’t need.

So, already, we have a subtle difference: OUTsurance is simple, rewards prudence, and leans on digital ease. Santam is versatile, experienced, and—well—sometimes a bit overwhelming.

Pricing and Premiums: How Much Does Peace of Mind Cost?

Let’s talk money, because honestly, that’s often the make-or-break factor. OUTsurance is known for competitive premiums, especially if you’re a safe driver. They run a sort of “loyalty-cashback” system: the less you claim, the more you get back at the end of the policy year. In my experience, that can feel like a nice pat on the back for being careful. I once had a friend who went three years without a claim and received a noticeable refund—it wasn’t life-changing, but it certainly sweetened the deal.

Santam, on the other hand, can sometimes feel pricier upfront. You might pay more initially, especially if you customize your policy heavily. That said, their pricing often reflects the depth of cover. They offer several add-ons—like roadside assistance, replacement vehicle cover, and extended accidental damage protection—which can be valuable if you actually need them. But—and here’s where nuance matters—if you don’t take advantage of all those extras, you might feel like you’re paying for insurance you’ll never touch.

So, if you’re thinking strictly about monthly premiums and rewards for careful driving, OUTsurance may seem like a better deal. If you value extensive customization and don’t mind higher costs, Santam might justify the premium.

Claims Process: Smooth Sailing or Bumpy Road?

Nothing kills trust faster than a nightmare claims experience. Here, both insurers have their fans and detractors.

OUTsurance has built a reputation for speed. Their online claims system allows you to report an incident, submit photos, and track progress all from an app. I once had a minor fender-bender, and within a few days, the repair shop was booked, and the insurance was sorted. The process felt almost effortless. That said, some people have reported delays for more complex claims—especially accidents involving multiple parties or injury claims. So while they shine in simplicity, they’re not infallible.

Santam, in contrast, tends to be more procedural. Some people find this reassuring—they like knowing every step is documented and monitored. But others, myself included, sometimes get frustrated with the extra layers. You might need to speak with a claims assessor, get multiple quotations, and wait longer for approval. On the upside, if something goes seriously wrong, Santam’s thoroughness can pay off—they’re less likely to deny a valid claim because of missing documentation.

Customer Service: Who Actually Picks Up the Phone?

Here’s where anecdotes matter. Talking to real humans often gives a clearer picture than policy brochures.

OUTsurance generally earns high marks for customer service. When I called their helpline about a policy question, I got through quickly, and the agent walked me step by step through what I needed. Friendly, practical, no fluff. But, as with any company, there are outliers. Occasionally, customers report unhelpful responses or long waits—though that seems less common.

Santam’s customer service is a mixed bag. You may get an agent who knows exactly what they’re talking about—or one who reads the script without much personality. Because they’re larger and have more clients, response times can vary. Some people like the predictability of their processes, while others find the “slow but thorough” approach frustrating. Personally, I’ve experienced both ends: a very smooth call one day and a frustratingly drawn-out one the next.

Policy Options: Picking What Actually Fits You

This is where Santam might pull ahead—but only if you’re willing to spend the time to understand your options. Their policies are highly customizable. You can adjust coverage levels, choose different excess amounts, and add optional extras like cover for modified parts or special roadside assistance. If you drive a high-value vehicle or have specific lifestyle needs, that flexibility can be valuable.

OUTsurance keeps things simpler. You get standard comprehensive, third-party fire and theft, or third-party only. There are some add-ons, but not as many options to tinker with. This can be a blessing if you hate insurance jargon, but it may feel limiting if you’re trying to craft a policy that hits the sweet spot perfectly.

Rewards and Loyalty Programs: Does Being “Good” Actually Pay Off?

One of OUTsurance’s standout features is their cashback system. It’s not flashy, but it’s psychologically satisfying. The idea is simple: if you don’t claim, you earn back a percentage of your premiums. For someone like me, who drives cautiously and rarely has accidents, it’s almost like a small bonus for being responsible—a little reinforcement that careful driving has tangible benefits.

Santam doesn’t really do cashback in the same way. Instead, their value proposition is reliability, reputation, and customizable coverage. You might pay more, but the argument is that your peace of mind is worth the extra cost. Whether that resonates depends on your personality. If you like immediate, tangible rewards, OUTsurance has the edge. If you’re more concerned with long-term protection and reputation, Santam might feel more reassuring.

Real-World Scenarios: Who Fits Which Driver?

Let me throw in a bit of storytelling here. My cousin drives a small hatchback in Johannesburg. He rarely drives long distances, and accidents are few and far between. For him, OUTsurance’s cashback system and streamlined claims process made sense—it rewarded his careful driving and saved him some hassle when minor incidents did occur.

My uncle, on the other hand, drives a luxury SUV, often on longer trips across South Africa. He appreciates Santam’s depth of coverage and willingness to tailor a policy. If anything goes wrong, he knows the insurer has systems in place to handle complicated claims. He doesn’t mind paying a bit more upfront for that level of security.

These anecdotes illustrate a simple truth: “better value” depends heavily on your personal circumstances. There isn’t a one-size-fits-all answer.

Extras and Perks: Little Things That Make a Difference

Both insurers offer perks, but they’re framed differently. OUTsurance emphasizes digital convenience: an intuitive app, claim tracking, and quick communication. Santam leans on traditional assurances: thorough documentation, optional add-ons, and a network of approved repairers. Depending on what matters to you—speed and simplicity versus customization and depth—your perception of value may shift.

The Verdict: A Matter of Perspective

So, which is “better”? Honestly, it depends. OUTsurance may appeal more to everyday drivers who want simplicity, rewards for cautious behavior, and minimal fuss during claims. Santam may be better suited for drivers with specific needs, higher-value vehicles, or those who prioritize comprehensive, customizable coverage—even if it requires more effort to navigate.

If I were to distill it down: OUTsurance is like the friendly neighbour who’s always helpful and straightforward. Santam is the seasoned professional—reliable, experienced, and thorough, but sometimes a bit formal. Both have their merits, and your choice hinges on which qualities you value more.

My Personal Take

Having sampled both, I find myself leaning slightly toward OUTsurance for everyday driving. The cashback system and fast claims process resonate with my “less drama, more convenience” approach. But I completely understand why someone with a higher-risk vehicle or more specific coverage needs would opt for Santam.

Insurance isn’t just about cost; it’s about comfort and trust. And in that sense, there’s no wrong choice—only the one that aligns with your driving habits, risk tolerance, and patience for paperwork.

In short: compare premiums, consider your claims history, think about customization needs, and don’t forget the little perks. Your ideal car insurance isn’t necessarily the cheapest or the most comprehensive—it’s the one that fits your life in a way that makes you feel genuinely protected.

Published on: Sep 11, 2025

Related Post