Santam Car Insurance: Is It Worth the Premium?

I’ll be honest—whenever I see the word “premium” slapped onto an insurance product, I pause. It usually means two things: you’re going to pay more, but you’re also supposed to get more. The question is whether the “more” justifies the price. Santam, one of South Africa’s oldest and most recognized insurance companies, is a perfect example of this tension. They’ve built their reputation around being reliable, established, and yes, a little more expensive than some of their competitors. But is that higher price tag really worth it?

Let’s take a walk through what Santam offers, the trade-offs that come with it, and a few scenarios where paying extra might feel like money well spent—or maybe not.

A Brand with Legacy (and the Baggage That Comes With It)

When you talk to South Africans about car insurance, Santam’s name almost always comes up. They’ve been around since 1918. That kind of history gives them credibility. People think: They’ve been here for over a century, they must be doing something right.

I remember chatting to a colleague who swore by Santam. She had insured her Toyota Hilux with them for years, and when she had an accident on the N1 outside Paarl, Santam’s response was, in her words, “swift and no-nonsense.” The tow truck arrived in under 45 minutes, her claim was approved in days, and she was back on the road with a courtesy car. She shrugged and said, “Yes, I pay more. But when I need them, they’re there.”

That story captures the promise of Santam: stability, efficiency, and support when things go wrong. But the flip side of legacy brands is that they often move slower, stick to more traditional processes, and don’t always offer the cheapest or most flexible packages for younger, cost-sensitive drivers.

The Premium Price Tag

Here’s where Santam tends to raise eyebrows. Their premiums are often higher compared to companies like OUTsurance, Budget Insurance, or MiWay.

For example, I ran a quote exercise with two friends recently. One drives a 2018 Polo Vivo, the other a 2015 Ford Ranger. Both have clean driving records. For the Polo, Santam’s monthly premium came in about R450 higher than a competitor. For the Ranger, it was about R600 more. That’s not pocket change. Over a year, that difference is basically a holiday weekend in Durban.

Now, Santam would argue you’re not just paying for insurance—you’re paying for peace of mind, reliability, and a smoother claims process. And to be fair, many people do report that their claims handling is where Santam shines. Still, in a country where household budgets are already stretched, not everyone is willing (or able) to fork out that much extra for what is essentially an intangible promise.

What You Actually Get

Santam’s car insurance usually comes with:

Comprehensive cover – accidents, theft, fire, natural disasters.

Third-party liability cover – if you damage someone else’s property.

Optional extras – like roadside assistance, car hire, or cover for accessories.

One thing I noticed is that their policies often include benefits that others sell as add-ons. For example, they’re known for their “SOS services” which cover emergency roadside assistance, medical emergencies, and even things like sending a locksmith if you’re locked out.

On paper, that looks fantastic. But here’s the rub: not everyone needs or even uses all those extras. If you’re a 25-year-old driving a paid-off Kia Picanto mostly around town, you might not need the same coverage as a business executive clocking thousands of kilometers on South Africa’s highways every month. So, while Santam’s package is comprehensive, it might feel like buying a three-course meal when all you really wanted was a sandwich.

Claims: The Make-or-Break Factor

This is where Santam often earns its reputation. Claims handling is the heart of any insurer’s promise. If they can’t deliver here, all the fancy add-ons and glossy marketing don’t matter.

A friend of mine (let’s call him Sipho) once told me about his nightmare experience with a cheaper insurer. After his car was written off, he spent weeks calling call centers, submitting paperwork multiple times, and being passed from one agent to another. His payout was delayed by months, and by the end, he swore never to go with a “discount” insurer again.

By contrast, Santam generally scores well in claims satisfaction surveys. Many customers describe the process as smooth and professional. That reliability is what the extra premium supposedly buys. But not everyone has glowing stories. I’ve read complaints online about delayed settlements and disputes over repair costs. It seems that even Santam, with all its history, isn’t immune to the frustrations that plague the insurance industry as a whole.

So, is their claims handling better than most? It appears so. Is it flawless? Definitely not.

Who Might Find Santam Worth It?

Based on what I’ve seen and heard, Santam makes the most sense if you fall into one of these categories:

You drive a high-value car. If you own a brand-new Mercedes, BMW, or Land Rover, cutting corners on insurance feels risky. Paying Santam’s higher premiums may provide peace of mind that your insurer won’t quibble over details when your R1 million car is in the panel shop.

You travel a lot. Long-distance commuters, sales reps, and anyone who spends serious time on the road may value Santam’s strong roadside and emergency services.

You’ve had bad experiences elsewhere. Sometimes people are willing to pay more simply because they’re tired of the runaround with cheaper insurers.

You’re risk-averse. Some people just want the “sleep at night” factor. They don’t want to wonder if their insurer will show up when needed.

But if you’re young, budget-conscious, or driving an older car that’s already depreciated heavily, Santam’s price tag can feel unnecessary.

The Alternatives: Is Cheaper Always Worse?

It’s tempting to think cheaper insurance automatically means worse service. That’s not always the case. Companies like OUTsurance have built reputations for balancing competitive premiums with decent claims handling. Discovery Insure throws in wellness rewards and discounts for good driving habits. MiWay lets you manage everything online, which appeals to younger, tech-savvy drivers.

These alternatives may not carry Santam’s legacy weight, but they’re not necessarily “less safe” bets. In fact, for certain types of drivers—especially younger ones—the flexibility and affordability might outweigh the prestige of a big-name brand.

The Human Side of Insurance

Something I’ve noticed while writing about insurance is how personal these decisions really are. My mom, for instance, would never leave Santam. For her, the peace of mind of sticking with the “trusted old name” is worth every rand. She’ll cut back elsewhere before she changes her insurance. Meanwhile, my cousin in Joburg laughs at the idea of paying extra. “Why would I pay R800 more when I can get the same cover with OUTsurance?” he said. To him, brand loyalty is a waste of money.

These two attitudes highlight why it’s tricky to say definitively whether Santam is “worth it.” It depends not just on your car or your driving habits, but also on your tolerance for risk, your past experiences, and even your personality.

A Subtle Critique: Is Santam Too Comfortable?

Here’s one thing that nags me about Santam. Because they’re so established, I sometimes wonder if they’ve grown a bit too comfortable. They don’t always come across as the most innovative or customer-friendly in terms of digital tools or flexible policies. Competitors are experimenting with pay-as-you-drive options, telematics, and discounts for safe driving behavior. Santam, by comparison, feels more traditional.

That’s not necessarily bad—traditional often equals reliable. But in a market where customers want customization and lower premiums, being too traditional can also make you feel out of touch.

Final Thoughts: So, Is It Worth It?

So, back to the original question: Is Santam Car Insurance worth the premium?

If you’re someone who values legacy, stability, and the peace of mind that comes with a long-standing brand, then yes, Santam may absolutely be worth it. The higher premiums buy you a degree of reassurance that can be hard to quantify but very real when you’re in a crisis.

But if you’re younger, budget-conscious, or driving a car that wouldn’t justify the high premiums, it may not make sense. You might find that competitors offer enough reliability at a significantly lower cost, freeing up cash for other things in life.

For me? I’d say Santam is like dining at a fancy restaurant. You’ll get attentive service, well-prepared food, and the sense of being taken care of. But sometimes, a hearty meal at your favorite local spot—cheaper, simpler, still satisfying—does the job just fine. The choice depends on what matters more to you: the experience or the savings.

Published on: Sep 11, 2025

Related Post